I was ‘lucky’? enough to get an iPad the other day for reviewing. As a number of people I do work for have gotten one, or are thinking about getting one, I was certainly interested to put it through it’s paces. Apple has a lot riding on the iPad, and from a marketing standpoint, they have done an amazing job at building the hype, and keeping it going, unfortunately the actual implementation isn’t quite as polished as Apple’s advertising machine. Don’t get me wrong, there certainly are some things to like about the iPad, so I will cover those first.

What I liked:

  • Apple’s touch interface is quite good, and in the native applications it is quite smooth. The ability to pinch>zoom in and out is fantastic.
    While not a true multitasking machine, the ability to use the iPod application to listen to music, while doing other things is certainly nice (although true multi-tasking would have truly been great).
  • A very nice video display – videos that you can stream or download do look pretty good on the iPads screen
  • The amount of good applications available is also great, although I’m not hip on paying for them, much less giving Apple a 30% chunk of what should be going to the developers, but there really are some amazing apps available!
  • Battery life seems pretty good so far – I have been able to use the iPad off and on throughout the day and still have a good charge left.
  • Intuitive interface – most of the built in settings and apps are pretty easy to figure out, and they work well.
  • Ability to interface with Windows and Linux machines through apps like Remote desktop and XenApps – these are essential features in order for the iPad to have any real business use. In fact, most of the best applications which I have seen for the iPad rely on interfacing with non-Apple technology. The ability to pull up a Windows 7 remote desktop makes the iPad almost usable, and the XanApps are definitely a step in the right direction, although both are hampered by the iPad’s poor networking features
  • What I don’t like:

  • No Flash support – despite Steve (I wanna be god) Job’s opinion, Flash is a big part of the web and will be so in the immediate future. Since the iPad will never support Flash (big mistake) this is pretty much a deal breaker in terms of a truly worthwhile device as it means that a sizeable chunk of the web is not usable on the iPad, and the number of businesses who are refusing to abandon Flash immediately is growning rapidly – While I agree with Steve that Flash does have some issues, it is also an ever evolving platform, and the lack of Flash support on the iPad really is noticeable after some web surfing. I have always hated web browsing on smart phones exactly for this reason, no Flash, but luckily the Android platform is about to get Flash.
  • Some overpriced and real poorly designed apps in the app store – the problem with the app store, besides Apple’s obvious greed is that there are so many apps that you have to buy to try, only to find out that they are seriously lacking.
  • Non standards compliant wireless and poor wireless reception – many businesses and universities have banned the use of iPads because of the way the wireless doesn’t follow the rules. The wireless signals also seem to be hampered and slowed down considerably (on my laptop at home I easily get 25Mbps download speeds, on the iPad, I am lucky to see 3 – 5 Mbps). The wireless also drops out frequently, even with a strong signal. This is another deal breaker for me, as not having reliable connection to the internet makes doing any kind of business next to impossible.
  • Crappy, and I mean CRAPPY ATT wireless service. While I admit that Pensacola is not a Major metro area, ATT’s wireless service here is seriously lacking (I really wish they would allow Verizon to be the service provider). Having a signal that is constantly dropping in and out, and is slow at best most of the time is just not acceptable.
  • Lack of proper security features – this more than anything is a super deal killer (and beware businesses that have security requirements, especially health professionals and government contractors). The iPad is simply not secure. From it’s ability to be easily hacked, to the huge number of unsecure third party applications, the iPad is nowhere near ready to deal with complex security requirements like HIPPA and the US Government Comuter Security guidelines. This is one reason that many businesses ban Apple products from interfacing with Windows networks – they just aren’t secure (example in point is the annual hacking contest where a Mac was hacked in 20 seconds this year, not to mention how easy it is to jailbreak an iPhone or iPad). Not that Windows systems can’t be hacked, but both Windows and Linux have enterprise security features available that meet the regulatory requirements whereas the iPad has not been properly tested or certified.
  • Being tied to the Apple App store and their holier than thou attitude – Apple keeps a stranglehold on anything of theirs you buy, allowing only what they deem appropriate (and taking a nice cut of any profits of course). While it is very easy to jailbreak Apple products, it also voids any warranties and you never know when Apple might push an update that will ‘brick’ your hardware just out of spite. This is a huge contrast from Andriod apps which I can easily write myself and install on any Android device.
  • Having to replace my iPad when the battery dies – this is just plain STUPID – not having an easily replaceable battery, and having to send my iPad to Apple, along with $100, only to get a different iPad back- that sucks!
  • No usb ports or the ability to direct print – another thing that just plain sucks. Not being able to just pop in a flash drive to transfer files, or being able to print is a real big shortcoming
  • The verdict:
    While the iPad does have some nice features, and it certainly will spur the innovation in the market, in my opinion, it is definitely not worth the hefty price tag. It is really just a cool toy (although I do love to have cool toys!). It is definitely not ready for the enterprise or any kind of serious business useage, and while I have heard talk of businesses rushing out to adopt it into their business plans, I think they will find they are spending more time trying to use it that they were using their ‘clunky’ workstations or laptops. For an oversized iPod, it does have nice video display, but my recommendation is that unless you like wasting money, or have money to waste, wait a while to see what comes out in the next 6 months or so as there are certainly some very cool devices being developed that won’t have the shortcomings of the iPad.

     17 Apr 2010 @ 6:50 AM 

    The past few weeks have certainly been quite active in the technology world. From the much overhyped release of apple’s ipad to the pending release of Microsoft Office 2010, the press has certainly been filled with reviews, opinions and a lot of conflicting reports. There has also been an increase in Malware and virus attacks on the web, with more people’s computers falling victim to them – yes, even Apple computers are not immune to the bad things, and I had a good laugh when I saw that someone had hacked the new ipad less than 24 hours after its release.

    I got a chance to play around with an iPad, and overall I was underwhelmed and not very impressed. Although the touch features do seem to be quite good (something that Apple is great with), the things that the iPad lacks are just too much to make it anything but an overpriced toy. the iPad’s lack of Flash support means that a lot of sites on the web are unviewable, as are the majority of video’s and web based games – of course Apple would be more than glad to sell you apps for games and such (while taking a nice 30% profit from the developers pockets).  Then there is the fact that there are no USB ports, no camera, and the Wifi and battery have some serious issues. Also, Apple has now announced that they are going to be even more godlike in their control of what you can do with the hardware that people spend so much money to ‘own’ – sure, you own it, but Apple decides what you can and can’t do with it and what you can and can’t run on it. Personally, I will wait to see what the HP Slate tablet and Dell’s new Android based tablets will do as they are much more likely to actually have a value in terms of usability.

    Microsoft has officially RTM’d Office 2010 (RTM=Release to Manufacturing) and it is looking like a pretty good product – stay tuned for a review as soon as I get the final copy! Microsoft is currently offering a great deal where if you buy a copy of Office 2007 in the next few months, you are eligible to get a download copy of Office 2010 when it is released, see: http://www.microsoft.com/office/offers/home/2/ 

    I have recently noticed a big bump in Pensacola computer malware infections, with fake Antivirus applications leading the pack. These kind of infections are what they call ‘ Scareware ‘ – malware that is designed to scare you into either buying a worthless product, or in some cases trying to get your credit card number for nefarious purposes, and I have seen quite a few of these infecting computers in Pensacola FL the past few weeks. These scareware infections are designed to look like common security applications and come with names like ‘ Antivirus 7 ‘ (which resembles AVG), ‘ Antivirus 360 ‘ (which resembles Norton’s 360).

    Win Antivirus 7 Malware screenshot

    Win Antivirus 7 Malware screenshot

    One of the most common ways these applications are installed are when you are directed to a page, or get a popup warning you that you are infected with something nasty and to download a tool to help you  – the tool of course is the infection and it completely takes over your computer with even more false scary warning on how badly your machine is infected. The  real bad downside of these infections is that they open the door for even more infections that are even nastier in what they do. Many times if you catch these infections as soon as you get them, you can do a System Restore to help deactivate them. However, once they become rooted in your system they do all kinds of things to try to stop you from removing them like disabling system restore, disabling task manager, disabling your antivirus and also blocking you from downloading tools that can help kill them.

     For links to free and paid for antivirus/antispyware/antimalware software that can help protect you and remove some of these nasty infections visit Pensacola Computers Tech Page

    \/ More Options ...
    Change Theme...
    • Users » 1
    • Posts/Pages » 89
    • Comments » 23
    Change Theme...
    • VoidVoid
    • LifeLife « Default
    • EarthEarth
    • WindWind
    • WaterWater
    • FireFire
    • LiteLight
    • No Child Pages.